Letarte: The goat who wasn’t
Saturday, March 6th, 2010
Jeff Gordon with crew chief Steve Letarte in Las Vegas: In a “coulda shoulda woulda” world, somebody had to be the scapegoat for Gordon’s loss.
HAMPTON, Ga. - Now that Steve Letarte has been drug through mud in a fashion usually reserved for, say, the President of the United States, isn’t it about time someone - anyone! - examines what actually happened, without merely assuming that Jeff Gordon’s crew chief is the most noteworthy goat since Bill?
Bill was - and, generationally, is — the official mascot of the United States Naval Academy. Letarte isn’t literally a goat, so, to use the incarnation of "goat" that refers to "a victim of ridicule or pranks," Letarte is, at least for the moment, being compared to the likes of Mickey Owen, whose dropped third strike cost the Brooklyn Dodgers the 1941 World Series; Jackie Smith, who dropped a crucial pass for the Dallas Cowboys in the 1979 Super Bowl; and Bill Buckner, who greatly assisted the Boston Red Sox in blowing the 1986 World Series.
The problem? Letarte did nothing wrong. Gordon dominated the race but didn’t win, so there had to be - to borrow another form of goat - a scapegoat.
Also, hindsight is 20/20.
The truth is that Letarte and, by extension, Gordon were in the worst of situations for the competitive sportsman. They were - drum roll, please - "damned if you do and damned if you don’t."
After Letarte and Gordon made their fateful decision to pit for two tires and the green flag waved for the final time, there were 34 laps remaining in Las Vegas Motor Speedway’s Shelby American (though it sounds like the name of a high-school graduation honor - this year’s Shelby American is Melissa Dickert! — it was actually the name of a Sprint Cup race).
Had Gordon received four tires on that final pit stop, he might have prevented Jimmie Johnson from winning the race, but it doesn’t mean he would’ve won it. Gordon led for 17 laps after the pit sequence, but a full set of tires eventually enabled Johnson to slip past and pull away. Gordon wound up third after leading 219 laps, or 82 percent of the race.
In the circumstances that occurred near the end of that race, the leader sets the strategy for everyone else. If Gordon had pitted for four tires, a good many of the drivers behind would have opted for two. Since Gordon took two tires, most of those pursuing him took the full set. He actually restarted second because Clint Bowyer’s crew didn’t change any tires at all. Also changing two tires, by the way, was Kevin Harvick, who ended up finishing second, ahead of Gordon.
Had Gordon changed all four tires, he probably would have been sixth or seventh, not second, when racing resumed. He may have been able to regain the lead, but he wouldn’t have had the oft-cited "clean air" that goes to the driver out front.
Since he only changed two, only Harvick followed his lead. Gordon and Letarte had hoped others would join him in the two-tire gamble.
But … because they did … others didn’t.
If they had … others … wouldn’t have.
So criticize Letarte if you want. But if he’d changed four tires, the odds are that fans would have screamed at that, too.



Juan Pablo Montoya came into the Texas Motor Speedway media center dressed in a uniform that said:
